Cathedral Square was one of my favourite places in old pre-quake Christchurch. It was an eclectic place filled with interesting buildings, interesting shops, and interesting people. The architecture in and around the Square was a fascinating mishmash of building styles that captured the development of Christchurch from a settler town to modern city. From Victorian period Gothic stonework and Italianate brickwork, to Edwardian Baroque, perpendicular Gothic, and Italian High Renaissance, to Art Deco, to the concrete and glass office blocks, banks, and hotels of the mid to late 20th century.

The building that stood out the most, of course, was the Anglican Christ Church Cathedral.

Designed by English architect Sir George Gilbert Scott with significant amendments by prominent Christchurch architect Benjamin Mountfort, the Cathedral is a Category 1 Historic Place on the Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga List and a scheduled Heritage Item on the Christchurch City Plan. Construction began in 1864 but was halted in 1865 due to finances. This early construction would see the laying of the foundations and little else. Construction would be picked up again under the direction of Montfort in 1873. It was completed in 1904 under Benjamin’s son, Cyril Mountford who had followed in his father’s footsteps to become an architect. Benjamin Mountford died in 1898, never having seen the completion of the building.

In mid 2011 I was hired by Katharine Watson (then owner of Underground Overground Archaeology Ltd, now one of the founders of the Christchurch Archaeology Project) as an archaeologist to help with recording the huge number of 19th century buildings to be demolished and subsurface archaeological sites that had the potential to be damaged during the rebuild of the city. In July 2011 I was given access the CBD red zone, and one of the first things I did was visit the Cathedral.

This post is simply a collection of photos of the Cathedral that I took over my time in the red zone.

Photo I took of the Wizard in front of the Cathedral in 2004, using an awful 2 megapixel camera.

There is a lot of talk at the moment of the decision to halt the repairs to the Cathedral and mothball the building due to financial difficulties. This has upset some who would prefer to see the building restored quickly, and others who would prefer to remove it altogether rather than have an unfinished building and reminder of the earthquakes in the heart of the city.

Personally, I think it should be safely mothballed and the restoration finished when finances allow. Losing the last part of the iconic historic architecture in the Square when Christchurch has already lost so much would be an absolute travesty.

Today we live a very fast paced lifestyle that demands immediate results. This is a modern way to view the world. In the past it was common for projects to be started that would take decades or even centuries to complete. Our ancestors waited 40 years for the Cathedral to be finished. I see no harm in showing the rebuild a similar patience.

Christ Church Cathedral April 2011

CERA began reducing the CBD red zone in March 2011, starting with zone 1 between the Botanic Gardens and Cambridge Terrace. In April 2011 my girlfriend (now wife) and I took a walk through zone 1 and snapped a shot of the Cathedral from the Worcester Street bridge.

A steel frame had been added to the gable above the rose window. This was ancored into the stonework via steel rods. Unfortunately it would do little to stop the gable from collapsing.

Christ Church Cathedral July 2011

In July 2011 I was given CBD red zone access to help with the archaeological recording of the CBD demolitions. I visited the Cathedral that month. The steel frame that had been attached the to the front of the building had largely failed to do much to stabalise the failing facade. About a third of it had collapsed, taking with it almost all of the rose window.

The remains of the tower. The debris are from the top part of the tower. One of the bells is visible to the left. The exposed side had been pulled out by a digger the day of the earthquake to rescue survivors. The week before the earthquake my wife and I had come into the Square and had sat on the concrete lip just beyond the crushed bench.

Deconsecration

By the time of the deconsecration of the Cathedral in November 2011 the CERA compound had been moved from Manchester Street to the Square, to the east of the Cathedral. The archaeology team, which had grown to about 7 or 8 people, occupied one of the portacoms within the compound. I nipped out to view the deconsecration ceremony before heading out to another potential archaeological site. (Standing well back of course, so that my high vis, work boots, and helmet didn’t distract from all the nice suits).

Bishop Victoria Matthews and Dean Peter Beck.

Christ Church Cathedral April 2012

By April 2012 more of the front gable had collapsed, taking with it the last portions of the rose window.

Demolition of the Cathedral tower – May 2012

The remains of the tower were reduced to only a few metres to make the site safe. The removal of the north wall had left the structure weak and at risk of collapse.

I'm particularly fond of this photo, with the news camera in the bottom left and engineers suspended above the tower.

Published On: 22 September 2024 / Categories: Anglican, Christchurch, Church, Historic Buildings, Religion, Victorian New Zealand /

One Comment

  1. Paul Hooper 22 September 2024 at 4:58 pm - Reply

    A fascinating account of the pre earthquake story of the cathedral together with an extensive version of events since. A good read Matt

Leave A Comment